To Dig, or Not to Dig: Breaking Down Soil-Management Methods

Deciding whether to turn soil or to build fertility without mechanical disturbance has become a defining question for homesteaders seeking to balance productivity with environmental stewardship. Tilling offers the advantage of a fine seedbed and rapid incorporation of organic matter, whereas no-dig systems depend on surface mulches and thriving soil organisms to cultivate fertility over time. Each method brings its own benefits and considerations, influenced by soil type, climate and plot size. In this article we explore their origins, regional suitability and practical outcomes, drawing on real-world examples to guide your choice.